Governments trying to agree global shipping fuel rules face an unresolved question over how to secure compliance without financial penalties, Hellenic Shipping News reported, citing Platts. Edmund Hughes, the International Bunker Industry Association’s representative to the International Maritime Organization, said on 12 November that support for a marine fuel greenhouse gas intensity standard had not translated into agreement on its financial provisions.

IMO member states are scheduled to discuss the Net-Zero Framework between 23 November and 4 December, following their failure to adopt it as planned in October 2025. The current proposal combines progressively tighter greenhouse gas intensity limits for marine energy over 2028-2035 with charges for shipping companies that miss the standards. Washington opposes the financial component, characterising it as a global carbon tax on shipping, while several countries have suggested revisions to seek a compromise.

The cost difference between conventional bunkers and lower-carbon alternatives remains central to the debate. According to the Platts global bunker cost calculator cited in the report, average October delivered costs in Singapore were $22.78 per gigajoule for 0.5% sulphur fuel oil, against $27/GJ for B24 bioblend, $28.48/GJ for LNG and $48.47/GJ for fully sustainable methanol. Supporters designed the framework’s financial provisions to encourage uptake of low-carbon fuels, whose limited availability keeps them more expensive than oil-based alternatives.

Speaking at the IBIA Annual Convention 2026, Hughes said shipowners could not be expected to keep purchasing costlier fuels while competitors avoided that expense. Any revised framework would therefore need another means of securing compliance and addressing the price gap. Most Pacific Island states and EU members still formally support the existing proposal, while the US and Middle Eastern states oppose it. Japan, China, Norway and several major flag states have offered alternative compliance ideas.

Hughes also stressed the bunker sector’s preference for global rules that clarify compliance obligations and future fuel requirements. He argued that renewed consensus-building could help secure worldwide implementation. The framework’s current text won approval from 63 countries in April 2025 after the US left negotiations, but 57 countries subsequently voted to postpone adoption in October 2025. For Hughes, the reliance on votes demonstrated that a shared position had yet to emerge.